Why Business Valuations Arrive at Different Values for the Same Company

Andrew Thompson • January 3, 2023

Every investor, business owner, and potential buyer understands how tricky valuing a business can be. The heart of this challenge surrounds two key variables: 1) the earnings of the business, projected over time in the future, and 2) the risk associated with buying the stream of earnings of a business, as calculated based on a discount rate.

To the current owner of the business, the arithmetic is very simple. He is solving for the amount he wants to get when he sells the business by using his present estimated earnings multiplied by an industry-accepted multiple of earnings to come up with a sales price valuation for the company.

So, for example, he may be estimating his current year’s cash flow based earnings at $800,000. He then applies the multiple he’s heard or read that other businesses in his space have received in the recent past. Let’s say that number is in the range of 5-8, and he’s convinced the halfway point between them, 6.5 is a good compromise. Voila! His business is worth $5,200,000 ($800,000 * 6.5). Now if he can just find the buyer who will pay him that amount for the business, everyone will be happy.

It just happens there is at least one searcher out there looking to buy a business that is much like the seller’s. He’s looking for stable, growing earnings, long-term, renewing contracts as receivables, and a seller who is ready to exit. The buyer’s goal is to get into this business for a long time horizon (10-20 years). In terms of what the parties are looking for, these guys are a good match.

To the buyer, however, the arithmetic is a bit different. He sees a company that reports $250,000 a year, consistently, on its tax returns, operating in an industry with sales multiples of 4-6 times average annualized earnings over a period of years. He knows there are some reasonable adjustments to be made to the cash flow of the business to account for certain expenses that fall outside the ordinary and necessary realm of the business’s operations.

But when he looks at industry standards and averages of companies this size in terms of add-backs to net income, he doubts if there can be more than another $250,000 in sustainable net cash flow, over and above what is reported on the seller’s returns. This, the buyer concludes he is looking at a company with sustainable earnings of no more than $500,000, with a reasonable multiple to apply to those earnings of five times, and concludes he should pay $2,500,000 or less if he is to buy the company.

So we have two interested parties who are a long way apart from where they would be willing to meet and make a deal. $5,200,000-$2,500,000 =$2,700,000 to be exact. Can they get together on a price? It’s possible, and part of it depends on how motivated each of them is, as well as how the deal will be financed.¹

But it wouldn’t hurt either of them to have a certified valuation professional look more closely and help either or both sides determine the price the deal should really be closed on. Take this all a step further. What if we’re not looking at the issue of a willing buyer or seller, but rather what if this is a business owned by someone in the middle of a divorce? How would that impact the value?

Or what if the business was part of a much larger estate, which was comprised largely of substantial tracts of valuable real estate, about to be passed, at least in part, to the living descendants of the owner? What would the valuation for tax purposes look like?

There are other examples where different conclusions of the value of the company may come into play as well: bankruptcy, liquidation, taking a company public or choosing to market the company to investors through a private offering.

You might want to assume that a company has one value on any given day and that is what it is worth. But that’s probably a bit of a short-sighted conclusion. When you consider all of the different possibilities and reasons for a valuation, perhaps you can see how what the company is worth on a given day is truly dependent on why you are valuing the company.

This is counterintuitive to the point that, without deeper thought, it might even seem dishonest. But it’s actually closer to the pinnacle of honesty than vice versa. Granted, there are many values a person could assign that are just wrong and indefensible, but there are several value conclusions that would be correct, depending on the purpose of the valuation.

In our example above, the buyer and the seller came up with two very different values for the company, presumably as of the same date for each. In no way does this mean that the seller’s value was wrong, nor the buyer’s. The higher value was what the seller would assert the company was worth to him on that date. Meanwhile, the buyer would tell you he is calculating what he thinks the company is likely to be worth to him, on the same date.

In other words, the seller is telling the buyer and anyone else in the conversation, what he is prepared to sell the company for – what he believes it is worth, and what you could write him a check for and he would turn over the keys to the company. The buyer, however, is telling you what he is already prepared to pay for the company, not necessarily what he would ultimately be willing to pay.

Both parties may be willing to move from these numbers, and eventually, even agree on a price. If and when they do, then we know the true transaction value of the company, that is the agreed-upon price for that particular transaction, but even that may not be based on the most reasonable conclusion of the fair market value of the company.

What? I’m sure that last sentence is more than a little confusing. But remember, fair market value is a function of what a hypothetical, willing, and reasonable buyer and seller would agree to as the price for the company. This is frequently different (frankly, often a bit less, but could be more) than a transaction price. Just because these two, particular willing parties agree on this price, it doesn’t mean that every willing buyer and seller, nor that any other buyers and sellers would agree on the same price.

It is frequently the case in M&A transactions that when a deal does not work out, the price for which the company ultimately sells will be very different than the price agreed to the first time around. If an actual transaction price reflects fair market value, which actual price is it then? Fair market value, like most forms of valuation, is not dependent on the parties involved. It exists independent from the transaction, and, once the rules of valuation are properly applied, it is also an objective (albeit actually arbitrary in some respects) measure of the value of the company.

Perhaps some analogous examples would be helpful to better illustrate what we’ve explored above. Let’s say, for example, you have a 2015 Corvette, that you would have no intention of letting go for less than $80,000. You’d rather keep it for yourself than sell it for less – or at least that’s what you think when the day begins. The best sources of market value, however, say that in a pure street sale, the car should bring about $70,000.

An IRS agent has been assigned to audit your assets, which is never good news, and she has suggested that because the car has low miles and is in incredible condition, it ought to sell for $90,000. Thankfully for you, you have a Certified Valuation Analyst who is able to counter the IRS, based on some limitations on marketability, liquidity and the fact that the car is actually owned by a club you are just a 40% minority partner in, and informs the IRS she believes the proper value to assign to the car is $50,000.

While you’re showing the car at a show, an interested buyer approaches you. He’s been looking for a deal on the exact model of the car you own, hoping to pay no more than $60,000 to get it. After checking out all of its features and its condition, and knowing you’re not going to let it go cheap, he offers you $68,000. You tell him what you’re prepared to take for it, at which point he counters, and eventually, the two parties agree on a price of $75,000, with the approval of the club owners, of course – done!

So what is the value of the car? The correct answer is always – it depends. But it’s no different with the value of a business. It depends. Interestingly, going back to our car analogy, this issue of value was recently adjudicated for the car in question in a divorce case.

The husband/owner, the same one who wouldn’t part with his precious toy for less than $80,000, had his IRS valuation expert testify that the value he had in the car was right around $50,000. Meanwhile, the wife also had an expert who was more aggressive than the IRS itself and suggested it was worth at least $95,000.

So what value did the court assign to the car? Well, it could have done what a judge in Indiana once did – ask the husband’s attorney which valuation to rely on and then turn around and ask the wife’s attorney whether she wanted half of that in cash or the car. That will keep a valuation expert focusing on what is reasonable.

But in this case, the judge decided to do what is most common, but not universal, in divorce cases and split the valuations down the middle, assigning a value of $72,500, 40% (the husband’s share in the club that owned the car) of which was part of the marital estate. The husband then paid one-half of that amount to the wife, so she received a net amount of $14,500 for 50% of his interest in the car, on top of the other assets she received from the distribution of the marital estate.

Now let’s analyze some comparative data from this hypothetical situation.

In descending order, we have valuations from:

  1. The wife’s divorce expert - $95,000
  2. The IRS - $90,000
  3. The Seller’s ask - $80,000
  4. The sales price - $75,000
  5. The court-assigned value - $72,500
  6. The Blue Book FMV - $70,000
  7. The Buyer’s opening bid - $68,000, and
  8. The husband’s divorce expert - $50,000

So let’s talk about these numbers consequentially. First of all, it isn’t necessarily common for the experts on divorcing spouses to be so far apart on valuation numbers. But it is very common for the expert of the spouse who does not possess the property to come up with a somewhat higher value on assets. The wide disparity between those numbers in our example just makes for an easy illustration of the points we’re trying to make.

The wife’s expert could reasonably be expected to be even higher than the IRS’s number since the IRS needs to allow for certain discounts of value for lack of control and lack of liquidity. While a seller might wish to get even more than the IRS or his wife’s expert would assert, his knowledge of the actual market might inform him that he wouldn’t be likely to sell to anyone at those prices.

The actual sales price, of course, was merely the price agreed to by the buyer and seller, but it’s quite interesting, and common as well, that the sales price was just a bit higher than either the court-assigned value or the Blue Book value. What’s the explanation for this?

The most interesting thing about the court-assigned value is that it is so close, and wedged between, the sales price and the Blue Book pricing. Thus, there’s a good sanity check on the court’s work, but it’s a check the court couldn’t perform until the sale actually occurred.

On the other, there is another, less widely used, tool an analyst can use to validate the sanity of these numbers. While there is no general consensus on the psychology and motivations of buyers, there is considerable data that shows it is more likely for an actual, willing buyer and seller to agree on a price that is slightly higher than FMV than it is for the price to be lower than FMV.

Why is that? My own perspective on this question is that the dealmaking instincts of a buyer and seller dictate that the seller already knows what price he will walk away from a deal at, while the buyer is only thinking he is there to make a deal. In other words, there is always more pressure for the buyer to move up in price to keep the deal open than there is downward pressure on the seller who stands ready to walk away and keep what he already has rather than lower his price too much.

Another way of looking at it is to recognize that the buyer will walk away with his money, but nothing to show for it if a deal doesn’t get done, while the seller will drive away in the car he keeps if the deal doesn’t happen.

We’ve taken a fairly extensive walk through the maze of basic valuation concepts in this post, with the goals of helping our readers better understand the need for high-level valuation work and also how many different valuation numbers can be valid and legitimate, as long as the rules for the type of valuation being conducted, are followed.

 

Whatever questions you have left in mind, please contact Andrew Thompson of Landmark Valuation Advisors.

¹ This post stops short of trying to explain the process of how a buyer and seller come together on price, if in fact they do. It’s common for either or both to have intermediaries negotiating terms for them until the find a price where it makes sense for them to move ahead with a Letter of Intent and the due diligence process. All of that is subject matter for another day. To simplify, however, for purposes of this post, you might think of the seller having an Asking price and the buyer offering a Bid price.

 

October 24, 2026
The landscape of federal fraud enforcement has fundamentally shifted. With the recent announcement of the $25 million Fraud Whistleblower Incentive Program (WHIP), the federal government is heavily crowdsourcing its anti-fraud efforts. American citizens are now financially incentivized to report suspected fraud operations in their communities to federal authorities, earning a 1 percent commission on the total dollar amount recovered. With the administration reporting that it has already uncovered $260 billion in fraud—and asserting that this is only a fraction of the true total—enforcement actions are aggressively ramping up. Recent federal raids on health care facilities and the seizure of properties allegedly purchased with misappropriated SNAP funds signal a zero-tolerance policy toward fraud. For the public, this dual-pronged approach creates unprecedented opportunities and substantial legal perils. Whether you have discovered massive fraud and want to report it safely, or you find yourself unexpectedly in the crosshairs of a federal investigation spurred by an incentivized tipster, navigating this environment requires highly experienced legal counsel. At Landmark Advocates, we understand the complex mechanics of federal fraud law from both sides of the aisle.
October 16, 2026
If you or someone you care about has ever faced criminal charges, you already know the potentially crushing weight of the justice system. The anxiety is paralyzing. The uncertainty about your freedom, your job, and your family’s future can make you desperate for a way out. In that moment of profound vulnerability, the prosecution will at some point try to slide a piece of paper your way using your attorney as the messenger: the plea offer. It may look like a life raft. It promises certainty. It offers at least a bit of a known outcome instead of the terrifying spectre of a trial. You sign your name, the judge walks you through a plea “colloquy”, determines his agreement, gives you your final sentence, then gavels the case closed, and you finally take your first deep breath in months. But fast forward a year, or five years, or ten. For a staggering number of people, that initial wave of relief inevitably curdles into deep, immovable regret. Because when you sign a plea agreement, you are not just accepting a guilty plea; you are accepting an outcome that may still be left to the judge’s discretion, and a permanent redefinition of your life. Before you put your pen to that paper, you need to be absolutely, undeniably sure you’re doing the right thing for you - today and in the future. The Conveyor Belt of Justice The reality of the modern American criminal justice system is not found in dramatic courtroom speeches or surprise witnesses. It is found in conference rooms and crowded hallways where futures are bartered away in minutes. Recently, the United States Supreme Court handed down a landmark decision in Hunter v. United States (June 2026), a case that pulled the curtain back on just how coercive agreements have sometimes become. In his concurring opinion, Justice Neil Gorsuch—joined by Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson—delivered a searing indictment of the modern system. “In our times, the jury trial has given way to a conveyor belt of plea bargains,” he wrote. He is exactly right. The system is no longer designed to test the government’s evidence; it is designed to process human beings as efficiently as possible. In Hunter , the defendant was indicted on charges that threatened him with up to 300 years in prison, as if he could live that long, and a $10 million fine. Faced with that apocalyptic scenario, he did what the overwhelming majority of defendants do: he took a bargain. He agreed to plead guilty to a single count involving roughly $38,000, and critically, he signed a waiver giving up his right to appeal. But the "conveyor belt" is not designed to be fair. Despite pleading to the $38,000 amount, the judge sentenced him based on uncharged conduct to repay a total of nearly $500,000, drastically increasing his prison time to 51 months. Because he had signed an appeal waiver, the government argued he had no right to fight back, even if the sentence was fundamentally flawed. While the Supreme Court ruled that an appeal waiver cannot be enforced if it results in a "miscarriage of justice", it made the holding very, very narrow and difficult for the typical defendant to use. The bigger lesson is chilling. Prosecutors routinely overcharge, stacking indictments so high that even an innocent person might be terrified into taking a plea just to avoid the risk of spending the rest of their life in a cage. Even then, they may find that a judge enters a sentence for a far longer period than they even thought possible. The conveyor belt is constantly moving, and the pressure to step onto it is immense. The Hidden Costs to the Prime of Your Life If you are between the ages of 18 and 45, you are in the critical building phase of your adult life. This is the window where you establish your career, buy a home, start a family, and build your financial foundation. A criminal conviction is a wrecking ball to every single one of those pillars. When you enter a plea agreement in court, the judge will tell you about the direct consequences: the probation, the fines, or the jail time. Sadly, many times these terms are more than what you anticipated when you signed the plea because the prosecution is skilled and artful at building in discretion for the judge to make your sentence worse than you expected. But if you can imagine there is something even worse, the reality is that what they do not spend hours explaining are the collateral consequences—the invisible chains that you will wear long after your formal sentence is complete. You might lose professional licensing. If you are a nurse, a teacher, a financial advisor, or a commercial driver, your career could evaporate the minute the plea is entered and you are guilty of a crime. Background checks have become universally standard; a felony or a crime of dishonesty on your record will immediately disqualify you from countless job opportunities, effectively capping your earning potential for decades. Housing applications get rejected. Your credit can be impacted. If you are not a U.S. citizen, a seemingly minor plea deal can trigger immediate deportation proceedings, tearing you away from your family. We see this all the time. Someone accepts a plea deal because they just wanted to avoid jail and "get it over with." Three years later, they are clean, sober, and trying to advance their career, only to hit a brick wall every time a background check is run. They realize, too late, that the quick fix was a permanent trap. They traded temporary peace of mind for a lifetime of closed doors. The Danger of the Willing Lawyer Perhaps the most tragic part of the "conveyor belt" is that some defense attorneys are all too willing to help operate it. It is an uncomfortable truth in the legal profession, but it needs to be said: a plea deal is easy. It requires less paperwork, less preparation, and less conflict. And to the client, it often seems like an easy way out at the time as well. When you hire a lawyer, you are entrusting that person, literally, with your life. But if your lawyer’s first instinct is to immediately ask the prosecutor for a deal, you are in danger. A lawyer who operates strictly as a plea negotiator is not defending you; they are simply facilitating your surrender - when the opportunity is always there to fight for your rights. Pleas are entered frequently when defendants feel pressured by their own counsel. The lawyer points out the towering stack of charges—just as in the Hunter case—and tells the client that a trial is very risky. While it is a lawyer’s duty to provide an honest assessment of risk, it is also his job to fight. If the government cannot prove its case, or if the police violated your constitutional rights to obtain their evidence, riding on the conveyor belt is a tragedy. You need a defense that pushes back against the machinery, not one that greases the wheels. Serious charges deserve a defense that starts with planning for the outcome you desire. You may be able to get that - you may not. Either way, you deserve the best effort toward that end. If your goal is a negotiated resolution, we will pursue that with aggressive care, but even then, our focus remains on ensuring that your rights are protected and that you are not strong-armed into signing away your future. And if a plea is not your intent, we come to the case with a very different posture. We prepare to seek a dismissal. We prepare to take the case to a jury trial. We prepare to hold the government to its heavy burden of proof, exposing reasonable doubt wherever it exists, and giving you your life back intact. We understand the stakes. We know that your liberty, your clean record, and your ability to build a life at whatever stage you are now, is on the line. We cannot guarantee a specific result—no honest lawyer can—but we can guarantee that we will zealously advocate for your rights in the manner you choose to pursue them. Take Control of Your Future If you are facing a serious criminal charge, do not let panic dictate your future. Do not sign a plea agreement just because the system makes it convenient. Once that signature is on the page and the judgment is entered, unwinding a bad deal through post-conviction relief or an appeal is monumentally difficult. Remember that - once the plea is entered, you can’t undo it. Take a deep breath, step back and think clearly. Then speak to an experienced criminal defense attorney who is prepared to fight for the life you want to keep. If you want a defense team that plans a strategy built on your goals, contact Landmark Legal Services. Call us at (317) 360-5174 or request a case evaluation now. Let’s talk about the real options for your future, before you sign it away.
By Admin • March 22, 2025
Hernia mesh, a medical device used to repair hernias, has been associated with serious complications, causing significant pain and suffering for many individuals. If you or a loved one in Indiana has experienced adverse effects from hernia mesh, understanding your legal rights is crucial. This post explores the legal avenues available to those affected by hernia mesh complications in the Hoosier State. The Risks Associated with Hernia Mesh While designed to strengthen hernia repairs, certain hernia mesh products have been linked to: Infections: Mesh can become infected, leading to pain, swelling, and further complications. Chronic Pain: Many patients experience persistent pain after mesh implantation. Mesh Migration: The mesh can shift from its original position, causing damage to surrounding tissues and organs. Adhesions: The mesh can adhere to nearby organs, leading to complications and the need for corrective surgery. Mesh Failure: The mesh may fail to provide adequate support, resulting in hernia recurrence. Indiana Product Liability Law and Hernia Mesh Claims In Indiana, product liability law allows individuals to hold manufacturers accountable for defective medical devices. To pursue a hernia mesh claim, you must establish: Defective Design or Manufacturing: That the mesh was defectively designed or manufactured. Failure to Warn: That the manufacturer failed to adequately warn about the risks of complications. Causation: A direct link between the defective mesh and your injuries. Damages: The extent of your injuries and losses. Steps to Take for a Hernia Mesh Claim in Indiana Consult an Indiana Medical Device Attorney: Seek legal counsel from an attorney experienced in medical device litigation. Gather Medical Records: Collect all relevant medical records, including surgical reports, diagnoses, and treatment plans. Document Your Symptoms: Keep a detailed record of your symptoms and how they have impacted your life. Understand Indiana’s Statute of Limitations:
More Posts